Pen Review: Edison Collier

 

Material: Acrylic
Nib: Steel, Medium
Appointments: Chrome / Steel colored
Filling System: Converter/Cartridge (Standard International)
Length (Capped): 152mm
Length (Uncapped): 131mm
Length (Posted): N/A
Section Diameter: 10mm
Barrel Max Diameter: 14.2mm
Cap Max Diameter: 16.4mm
Weight, Capped (with ink and/or converter): 28g
Weight, Uncapped (with ink and/or converter): 16g

When I purchased my Edison Beaumont early in 2013, it was only the 5th pen in my collection, and was the first “expensive” pen I had ever purchased. (At the time, I considered any pen over $100 to be very expensive…time has warped my thinking on that front, clearly.) The Beaumont was a nice pen, made from a great material, but it was the wrong shape and size for me, and I found it rarely getting inked as part of my rotation. Eventually, I gifted the pen to my grandmother, who loves the pen, and I was Edison-less for quite a while.

I recently decided to remedy my Edison-less state by purchasing a pen on the opposite end of Edison’s size spectrum–the gargantuan Collier in the new Blue Steel Material. This large, cigar-shaped pen is oversized, yes, but still eminently usable. For me anyway.

Edison Collier

Like every Edison pen I’ve ever handled, the Collier is an exquisitely made pen. There are few modern companies making pens with such incredibly tight tolerances. You can tell the folks at Edison take pride in the work they do. It shows in the fit and finish.  The high-gloss polish of the acrylic really shows off the deep, shimmery swirls of deep blue.

The Collier is a surprisingly light pen for its size, as it is an all-acrylic body (as are many of Edison’s pens.) That means that the cartridge/converter system can be set aside, and the pen can become eyedropper filled. If you are one of those people who need a lot of ink capacity (and I do mean a lot), this may be the pen for you.  I didn’t run a test, but I wouldn’t be surprised if the Collier could hold a solid 5-6ml of ink—the size of a Goulet sample vial if it were completely full.

I opted to get the stainless steel nib in medium on my Collier. This Jowo made nib was, while nice, nothing particularly special. It wrote with a little more feedback than I generally like, and ran just a touch drier than I generally like. I found this to be true with my earlier Beaumont. A bit of work on the nib (which I do with 95% of the pens that cross my desk, anyway) resolved both issues, and the pen writes wonderfully now.

Edison’s pens also come in 18k gold varieties, which I’ve never tried. They have also partnered with nibmeister Richard Binder to have him create a nib which has been altered to provide additional flex. I have been wanting to try the binder flex nib for a while, so I may see if I can purchase one of those to add to my pen at a later date.

In a lot of ways, I consider Edison pens and Franklin-Christoph pens to occupy the same strata of the pen world.  Both American-made pens, both small companies, both doing excellent, high quality craftsmanship. In fact, their pricing is quite similar as well in some cases. But in some ways, they are also the exact opposite of each other: Franklin-Christoph, whose Model 19 I simply adore, makes pens with different and unique designs, but using relatively understated materials and mundane cartridge/converter filling systems.  Edison, on the other hand, makes pens in more traditional shapes, but with spectacular and unique materials. And, on some of the custom pens, with more uncommon filling systems.

Frankly, both pens write so well and look so beautiful that I suspect there will be room for several more of them in my collection over the coming years.

 

 

  • bgray43050

    Thanks for posting! Glad you are enjoying the pen!

  • Bob M

    Great review thanks. I own two Edisons, a custom 76 and a Herald. Both on the bigger scale which I like. Brian is great to work with and his pens are great to write with.

  • Pingback: Fountain Pen Virus: Patient Zero - The Pen Habit()

  • Mystcreater

    Hi Matt. Another very great review about beautiful pen. A couple of weeks ago, I bought a Franklin-Christoph model 29 and I’m very glad about how the pen perform. A couple of days after buying this pen, I discovered the model 19 which is very nice. I love large pen.

    Tonight, I discovered the Edison Collier and I’m wondering to know which would be the best for me between the model 19 of Franklin and Edison Collier. Price is for me a factor of decision. I’m in Canada and with the currency rate, the Franklin pen is (195$US) 245$ CAD compared to the Edison at Wonderpens.ca at 175$ CAD + 8$ of shipping and taxes of about 25$ for a total of 210$.

    With canada custom, it’s like rolling dices when the package arrived if an additional 10$ of duties + taxes will be added which in this case, the Franklin can cost me more than 310$ CAD.

    Ok, is 100$ can be a valid reason to choose one instead of the other? Would it be a better deal for me to buy the Edison one?

    I want to let you know that I love both pens but after viewing your review about the Franklin 19 where you are singing while writing (ok, it’s a gold nib from Masuyama), I’m very not sure which one will give the best value.

    Thank you very much again for all your knowledge! 🙂

    • I suspect both will be great pens for you, especially if you get the steel nib version. It mostly boils down to which pen’s looks you like the best. I like the feel of the Collier’s section a bit more than the F-C, and if I were going with a factory steel nib, I generally prefer the more interesting materials Edison uses. But if I wanted a gold nib, or one of Masuyama’s nib’s, I’d go with the F-C in a heartbeat.

  • Pingback: Serious Nibbage Part 33: Edison Collier With Special Guest @PenHabit | Hey there! SBREBrown()

  • MKR

    Weight, Capped (with ink and/or converter): 16g
    Weight, Uncapped (with ink and/or converter): 28g

    Hmm, so the pen is lighter with the cap than without!