Custom Pen Review: Scriptorium Pens Chronicler

Material: Lava Explosion #3 Alumilite / Ebonite
Nib: 18k Gold
Appointments: Ruthenium
Filling System: Eyedropper
Length (Capped): 166mm
Length (Uncapped): 133.9mm
Length (Posted): N/A
Section Diameter: 11.9mm
Barrel Max Diameter: 14.9mm
Cap Max Diameter: 17mm
Weight, Uncapped (with ink and/or converter): 17g
Weight, Capped (with ink and/or converter): 21g

I first stumbled into the world of custom pens when a pen-friend of mine, Rob, lent me a custom pen he had ordered from Scriptorium Pens. I reviewed it and liked it so much I ordered a custom pen of my own before I had even returned Rob’s pen.

As much as I love acquiring production pens from the major manufacturers (and I do), there is something especially exciting about having a pen made to your own tastes and preferences. It allows you to tweak a pen to get exactly what you want. And I had a pretty specific design in mind for my first pen.


This pen was my first custom-ordered pen. I wanted to start with one of Renee’s stock models, the Chronicler. The Chronicler is a flat-topped model that takes its design queues from vintage pens like the Parker Duofold. I also knew I wanted the main body of my pen to be made from the luscious Lava Explosion #3 (Mineral Seas) Alumilite. And I knew I wanted to use a spare Pelikan M800 nib I had floating around in my pen toolbox. With those requirements in hand, I reached out to Scriptorium Pens and placed an order.


As part of the customization process, I asked about the possibility of making a few tweaks to the stock design. First, I wanted to use a different color material for the cap and barrel finials and for the section. (I am irrationally bothered by highly patterned acrylic where the pattern doesn’t line up where the pieces join, which I knew was likely with this matter.) I settled on black ebonite since I like the feel of ebonite in the hand for a grip section. I also asked about shrinking the size of the finials a bit in order to maximize the amount of the gorgeous Alumilite material that would make up the barrel.

What came back was a pen that met all of my goals for this model: a beautifully made pen from great materials that fits comfortably in the hand and writes like a champ.


The cap of the Chronicler is perfectly cylindrical in shape with a streamlined, Ruthenium-plated clip which has a small roller. I love the vintage look of this clip, but it feels a bit undersized for the size of the cap. The clip is extremely stiff and securely installed. The cap comes to a very thin cap lip, which feels a touch on the delicate side.

The pen’s barrel is also straight-sided, with a slight taper toward the bottom finial. The Chronicler comes in several sizes, and this large-sized barrel is quite large. When used as an eyedropper, it can hold a torrential amount of ink. The pen’s section has a lovely, curved, concave shape which is quite comfortable in the hand.


Assuming you don’t have an extra Pelikan M800 nib floating around, Scriptorium pens usually come with a #6 Jowo nib in either steel or 18 gold. With one of Jowo’s nib units, the pen can take standard international converters and cartridges. It can also be used, as mentioned earlier, as an eyedropper. With my nib, which was designed specifically for use on piston-filler pens, eyedropper fill is the only available option. I don’t have a lot of eyedropper filled pens, and find myself a little leery of the method, but it works well on this pen. (See the video for a short anecdote about filling the pen the first time…)

In construction quality, the Chronicler is exceptionally well-built. The shape is excellent, The pen is beautifully sanded and polished, and the joins between the materials are rock solid. The threads between the section and the barrel are tight and smooth. The only aspect of the construction that isn’t utter perfection for me is the threads between the cap and the barrel. They tend to feel a bit slack, and don’t mesh as smoothly as I might have expected. I’ve never had any issues with the threads getting crossed or with the pen’s cap coming loose—they just don’t feel completely smooth.

In the hand, the Chronicler is extremely comfortable. Alumilite is not a heavy material, nor is ebonite, so the feel in the hand is on the lighter side even despite the pen’s larger dimensions. The shape of the section is wonderful. There is only a minor step-down between the barrel and the section and has no impact of the feel of the pen in my hand.

This pen’s design doesn’t allow for posting. The opening in the cap will slip over the end of the barrel, but it doesn’t stay put once there. The inability to cap the pen doesn’t bother me, though, as the pen is long enough that posting is completely unnecessary.

The Scriptorium Chronicler is a great writer, but I won’t spend too much time on a review since the pen was fitted with one of my own nibs which I adjusted to my own preferences even before sending it to Renee for inclusion in the pen.


Custom pens are a lot of fun. You get to buy a pen that matches the materials, colors, shapes, and writing style that you’d desire. That customization, however, does come at a bit of a cost. (But perhaps not as much as you might think.) Renee’s pens start at $225, which puts them just slightly above the $150 price range for production pens you might get from Edison, Franklin-Christoph, Lamy, Platinum, Pelikan, Sailor, or Pilot. Special materials, multiple materials, gold nibs, or extreme customizations can add some extra to the price. I think that is an exceptionally reasonable price for such a well-made, handmade, custom-made pen.

  • KipKap

    Dang, that is a really pretty pen

  • Lez Cartwright

    I knew this was something special because of the introduction, you looked like a kid in a toffee shop, hahaha. Well, what a wonderful writing instrument, and surprisingly, it didn’t have to cost the house to be remortgaged. The ink is no longer made as I tried to get some but fortunately got 2 bottles of SBRE Brown / brown, which from Doc Stephen’s video on a comparison review looks close.
    Stunning material pattern which reminds me of some photo from the Hubble telescope. When I first read the title of the model I had the thought that maybe it was made from lava, a friend of mine has a pen made from lava off Mt. Etna which I believe is an Omas creation, anyway lovely pen and I’ve added it to my ‘Want One’ list.
    Thank you for your time and dedication.
    PS. Yeraguddun.

  • Pingback: Sunday Notes and Links | Fountain Pen Quest()

  • Allen Van Camp

    Matt, since the pen is an eyedropper, did she offer you the option of an ink window? Was it just a matter of not wanting to interrupt the flow of the acrylic pattern? I think if I had an eyedropper like that, I’d go for the window.

    • I’m sure I could have requested that as an option, but I wanted to maximize the Alumilite material. I like ink windows, but with this one, the barrel material was what I was after.

  • Matt Horgan

    Your reviews have convinced me, I ordered a Master Scrivener for my graduation in the spring. Specifically the Abalone Lava Explosion since I love some nice purples.

  • Neil Pollock

    I absolutely love the way this pen looks. I want to order one from Rene. Since you have had this pen for a while, are you still in love with it? and does she offer a discount like your PenHabit 10, 10% discount when ordering the pen? Let me know if there are any changes to the pen you would make since you have had a chance to spend more time with it… Thanks….Neil

    • No, she’s not offering a discount code for Pen Habit people. (Her backlog is around 4-5 months right now. I do still love the pen. I swapped out the Fine nib for an oblique broad, and that really made it shine even more.